What isn't right with the Current Standard DM Evaluation Model

Presentation Transcript

What isn't right with the Current "Standard" DM Evaluation Model? Ariel Linden, DrPH, MS President, Linden Consulting Group www.LindenConsulting.org All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Background (1) DM is advanced as a restorative cost- savings instrument with announced ROI's of up to 8:1 utilizing the " Industry Standard Evaluation Design " Conversely, the CBO and other writing audits have not discovered adequate confirmation to infer that DM projects can for the most part diminish the general cost of social insurance benefits All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without consent.

Background (2) Additionally, two DM programs have as of late hauled out of Medicare's firmly controlled Demonstration Projects and a third has reliably missed monetary targets. Instead of putting resources into endeavors to demonstrate that DM is undoubtedly financially compelling, the DMAA "Results Guidelines Report" is simply an underwriting of the norm All rights saved. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without authorization.

The Sales Pitch! "This precious report points of interest prescribed practices for measuring results in ailment administration programs—something likened to sound accounting guidelines—and thinks about wide industry accord ways to deal with results assessment." Yours for just $125! All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Statement/Question No two projects are similar (populaces oversaw, payers, neighborhood hone designs, intercessions, and so forth.,) and in this manner assessments can't and ought not be "institutionalized". As an industry, would we truly like to advance an assessment strategy that plainly benefits the seller over the buyer? All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without consent.

Purpose of this Presentation To represent how the populace based pre-post assessment configuration evokes money related outcomes for the most part for the DM program To portray how the business shields the act of utilizing a defective assessment approach, and Provide cases of how option strategies accomplish distinctive outcomes All rights saved. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Elements of the Current Model Pre-post configuration (program year short pattern year) with no control aggregate Per-part per-month (pmpm) cost is the essential result measure A "cost incline" for the non-incessant populace is utilized for anticipating where expenses would be, missing the program All rights saved. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Argument 1: Measurement at the populace level takes out RTM Identifying individuals utilizing claims information will overestimate costs in standard year (unbalanced number of high costing cases, failure to distinguish "obscure" cases) These same individuals will have diminished expenses in the following year All rights saved. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

RTM In A Cohort All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without consent.

RTM In A Population Diseases secured: asthma, CAD, CHF, diabetes Continuous enlistment in both years ≈ 65% All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Argument 2: "Overflow" impact is caught at populace level Physicians will apply changes in their practice designs (thus of DM) over every one of their patients and this will prompt to cost funds over the whole populace. Be that as it may, outside elements can without much of a stretch clarify changes that happen at the populace level, AND there is no writing on the "overflow" impact! All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

External Factors Impacting a Population All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Argument 3: Cost ought to be the essential result measure Total Cost = usage X unit value DM can affect use, however not unit estimating All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Inpatient Cost Trends Chronic disease Bed-days per 10,000 Annual Inpatient Cost Changes (%) Chronic Illness Bed-days per 10,000 Year over year cost changes All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without consent.

Argument 4: Cost ought to be contrasted with "non-endless pattern" An "incline" in light of cost will dependably be one-sided upward by surging unit costs A "drift" in light of usage will in all probability be level A "slant" in view of the non-incessantly sick populace might be higher Using just 2 information focuses presents predisposition All rights saved. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without authorization.

Comparison of "patterns" 7.5% expansion since 2000 Flat All rights saved. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without authorization.

Argument 5: A correlation gathering that is both proportionate and simultaneous may not be accessible in connected settings If the aggregate populace was not utilized as the estimation unit, a simultaneous control gathering would be accessible Historic controls can be identical on usage and quality measures Many vigorous assessment outlines have been connected to DM All rights held. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Real Examples The accompanying investigations speak to REAL cases in which elective techniques were utilized to test cases of extensive ROIs made by sellers. All rights saved. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Example 1 - Time Series Analysis All rights held. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without consent.

Example 2 - Time Series Analysis All rights held. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Example 2 - Time Series Analysis All rights held. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without authorization.

Example 3 – Year-Over-Year All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without authorization.

Example 4 – Matched Pairs All rights held. No bit of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without authorization.

Example 5 – Year-Over-Year All rights saved. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Summary (1) Measurement at the populace does not dispense with (or represent) RTM Identification in view of cases may likely overestimate the gauge costs because of relapse to the mean RTM will probably clarify some diminishment in costs All rights saved. No segment of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.

Summary (2) Using costs as an immediate result measure produces inclination because of the effect of unit estimating A "drift" in view of "non-chronics" may predisposition the outcomes for the seller All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Summary (3) There are a few systems that can be promptly connected to DM to assess results, which can be found at www.lindenconsulting.org Ariel's lead of DM financial assessment: use no less than 2 diverse research-based outlines and search for concordance of results. All rights saved. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Implications Purchasers will keep on questioning whether DM can spare cash the length of there are expansive contrasts in results between business assessments (utilizing the "standard" approach) and more hearty assessments Other human services frameworks are looking to the U.S. for direction as they contemplate the presentation of DM in their own nations. These issues might confine All rights saved. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any route without authorization.

Q & An Ariel Linden, DrPH, MS Email: alinden@lindenconsulting.org All rights held. No part of this introduction might be copied or utilized as a part of any path without consent.