Utilizing the Health Belief Model to Examine Differences in Mammography Compliance Among Black and White Women

1834 days ago, 694 views
PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Presentation Transcript

Slide 1

Utilizing the Health Belief Model to Examine Differences in Mammography Compliance Among Black and White Women Susan S. Thomas, Ph.D. 1 Victoria L. Champion, DNS, RN, FAAN 2 Theodore K. Mill operator, Ph.D. 3 Usha Menon, Ph.D., RN, ANP 4 1. Malignancy Prevention Fellow, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD. 2. Relate Dean for Research. Indiana University School of Nursing, Indianapolis, IN. 3. Teacher, Indiana University School of Public and Environmental Affairs. 4. Right hand Professor, University of Utah College of Nursing, Salt Lake City, Utah.

Slide 2

Abstract One of the best devices in early recognition of bosom disease is customary screening mammography. Current studies demonstrate, be that as it may, mammography use rates in the all inclusive community, and all the more so operating at a profit group, keep on falling beneath goals put forward by driving wellbeing offices. Thus, there have been endeavors to recognize wellbeing convictions that may affect screening mammography that are one of a kind to Black and White ladies. This cross sectional study utilized the Health Belief Model as the hypothetical premise of an auxiliary information investigation to set up contrasts in wellbeing convictions among Black and White ladies identified with mammography. Information were acquired from individuals from IU Medical Group or outpatients of the General Medicine Clinic of Barnes-Jewish Hospital. Information investigation was led utilizing basic condition displaying. Comes about demonstrate that for White ladies, the Health Belief Model speculated in this study clarified 13% of the fluctuation connected with mammography consistence and 9% for Black ladies. Also, there were contrasts between particular factors that seemed to have the most illustrative power for the two gatherings. These discoveries demonstrate that the Health Belief Model, while a decent beginning stage, does not totally clarify contrasts that exist between wellbeing convictions and their effect on mammography use for Black and White ladies.

Slide 3

Introduction One in nine ladies will create bosom tumor when she is 85 years of age (ACS, 1999). Dark ladies are more averse to create bosom tumor, yet more inclined to pass on therefore, somewhat because of later phase of bosom growth analysis (McDonald, 1999). Rates of mammography use in specific states, for example, Indiana and Missouri are underneath both Healthy People 2010 & ACS 2008 Objectives ( ACS, 2001). Wellbeing convictions are noteworthy indicators of mammography consistence (Stein, Fox, & Murata, 1991)

Slide 4

Aim of the Study The essential point of this study was to utilize the Health Belief Model (HBM) as the theoretical premise to look at wellbeing beliefs identified with screening mammography among Black and White women.

Slide 5

Methods Secondary information examination Cross sectional study Subjects (n=1045) Sites: General Medicine Clinic of Barnes-Jewish Hospital (St. Louis, MO) 2 HMOs in Indianapolis, IN – Methodist Medical Group & IU Medical Group Inclusion criteria: Women age 51 or more established No mammogram in past 15 months No individual history of bosom tumor Self-recognized as Black or White Having finished both Time 1 and Time 2 interviews

Slide 6

Instrumentation Champion Breast Health Survey (4 Subscales on Likert Scale) Perceived helplessness—3 things convictions of individual risk or damage identified with bosom disease Perceived advantages—7 things positive results of getting a mammogram Perceived obstructions—16 things feelings, physical or basic concerns identified with mammography practices Self-Efficacy—10 things conviction that one can effectively execute the conduct of acquiring a mammogram

Slide 7

Instrumentation (cont.) Breast Cancer Fear Scale (Likert scale) Fear—10 things saw danger of bosom growth joined by meddling contemplations, physiological excitement, and mind-set unsettling influences Powe Fatalism Inventory (Yes/No reactions) Fatalism—15 things conviction that demise is unavoidable when malignancy is available Demographic data Race, instruction, wage Mammography utilize

Slide 8

Data Analysis Exploratory information examination SPSS 10.0 Descriptive insights Structural Equation Modeling LISREL 8.3 Overall model in view of wellbeing convictions and demographic data created. Demonstrate tried for both Black and White ladies to inspect contrasts between two gatherings.

Slide 9

Results: Demographics

Slide 10

Results: Demographics The study comprised of 1045 ladies shape St.Louis, MO and Indianapolis, IN who were a piece of a bigger study to expand mammography consistence. Blacks made up 53% of the example and Whites involved the staying 47%. The normal age of the ladies was 65 with a mean training of 12 years, and 66% of the example completing 12 th grade. Over a large portion of the example (51%) had a wage that was $15,000 or underneath and 71% of the ladies were as of now not utilized.

Slide 11

Initial Hypothesized Model Education (1) Income (1) SES Susceptibility Scale Items (3) SUSCEPT Benefits Scale Items (7) BENEFITS COMPLY Mamcomp (1) Barriers Scale Items (16) BARRIERS Self-Efficacy Scale Items (10) SELFEFF Fear Scale Items (10) FEAR Fatalism Scale Items (15) FATALISM

Slide 12

Results: Model & Belief Variables * p < .05

Slide 13

Results: Model For White ladies, the Health Belief Model speculated in this study clarified around 13% of the difference connected with mammography consistence. For Black ladies, the Health Belief Model conjectured in this study clarified around 9% of the fluctuation connected with mammography consistence.

Slide 14

Results: Belief Variables For White ladies, the wellbeing convictions that were fundamentally identified with mammography consistence included: saw benefits, saw hindrances, and self-adequacy. Obviously, saw hindrances were conversely identified with and self-viability was straightforwardly identified with mammography consistence. For White ladies, be that as it may, saw advantages were contrarily identified with mammography consistence. When all is said in done, past research demonstrates that the inverse is valid, as a rule the more saw advantages of mammography that a lady has, the more probable she is to be mammography agreeable.

Slide 15

Results: Belief Variables For Black ladies, the factors altogether identified with mammography consistence were salary, seen benefits, saw boundaries, and dread. There was an immediate relationship amongst salary and mammography consistence. Sixty eight percent of the Black ladies in this study had livelihoods underneath $15,000.00, contrasted with 70% of the White ladies who had earnings above $15,000.00. Seen benefits have by and large been observed to be emphatically connected with mammography consistence in past studies (Aiken et al., 1994; Holm et al., 1999). On the other hand, there was a negative relationship between saw hindrances and mammography consistence, like results found by others (Philips and Wilbur, 1995).

Slide 16

Conclusions There seem, by all accounts, to be contrasts in mammography use among Black and White ladies that can be in part credited to wellbeing convictions. The HBM, while a decent beginning stage, does not appear to totally clarify contrasts that exist in wellbeing convictions or mammography conduct of Black and White ladies. Future Directions: Expand existing models of wellbeing conduct, for example, the HBM or investigate new models that join the current racial and financial inconstancy in the United States.

Slide 17

References Aiken, L.S., West, S.G., Woodward, C.K., & Reno, R.R. (1994). Wellbeing convictions and consistence with mammography-screening suggestions in asymptomatic ladies. Wellbeing Psychology, 13, 122-129. American Cancer Society. (1999). Disease raw numbers - 1999. (ACS Publication No. 5008.99). Atlanta, GA: American Cancer Society. American Cancer Society (b). (2001b). Tumor aversion and early location statistical data points - 2001. (ACS Publication No. 8600.01). Atlanta, GA: American Cancer Society. Holm, C.J., Frank, D.I., & Curtin, J. (1999). Wellbeing convictions, wellbeing locus of control, and ladies' mammography. Disease Nursing, 22, 149-156. McDonald, C.J. (1999). Tumor insights, 1999: Challenges in minority populaces. CA, 49, 6-7. Phillips, J.M., & Wilbur, J. (1995). Adherence to bosom growth screening rules among African-American ladies of varying work status. Growth Nursing 18, 258-269. Stein, JA, Fox, S.A., & Murata, P.J. (1991). The impact of ethnicity, financial status, and mental hindrances on utilization of mammography. Diary of Health and Social Behavior, 32, 101-113.