Most profound sense of being, Religion, and Health Interest Group SPIRITUAL STRUGGLE PATIENTS RELIGIOUS COPING Chaplain

1780 days ago, 807 views
PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Presentation Transcript

Slide 1

Most profound sense of being, Religion, and Health Interest Group SPIRITUAL STRUGGLE & PATIENTS' RELIGIOUS COPING Chaplain John Ehman University of Pennsylvania Health System September 7, 2005

Slide 2

Outline 1) terms & foundation 2) flow look into - measures/pointers - study comes about 3) clinical ramifications, peaceful viewpoint, and discourse

Slide 3

Terms/Concepts Currently Used in the Health Care Literature SPIRITUALITY opposite RELIGION

Slide 4

Number of Medline-Indexed English Articles by Year, with Keywords RELIGION, RELIGIOSITY , RELIGIOUS or RELIGIOUSNESS

Slide 5

Number of Medline-Indexed English Articles by Year, with Keywords SPIRITUAL or SPIRITUALITY

Slide 6

Number of Medline-Indexed English Articles by Year, with TITLES Using the Terms Religion/Religiosity/Religious/Religiousness and Spiritual/Spirituality

Slide 7

Characteristics of Definitions/Descriptions in the Current Health Care Literature: RELIGION — related with set up mystical customs and their social setting, authoritative opinion, hone (particularly custom), frequently with ramifications of set practices and once in a while extraneous inspiration SPIRITUALITY — related with an individual feeling of significance/qualities (regularly associated with religious conventions however not "bound" to these conventions or to belief in a higher power), with without further ado singular experience, with inborn inspiration, and frequently with an accentuation on constructive sentiments and connections and on fitness

Slide 8

A common meaning of deep sense of being in the present medicinal services writing Spirituality can be characterized extensively as that which gives individuals importance and reason in life. The definition that is utilized as a reason for medicinal school courses on deep sense of being and wellbeing is as per the following: Spirituality is perceived as a component that adds to wellbeing in numerous people. This idea is found in all societies and social orders. It is communicated in an individual's look for extreme importance through investment in a religion, however it can be considerably more extensive than that, for example, faith in God, family, naturalism, realism, humanism, and expressions of the human experience. — p. 690 of Puchalski, C. M., et al., "Deep sense of being, religion, and recuperating in palliative care," Clinics in Geriatric Medicine 20, no. 4 (November 2004): 689-714

Slide 9

Working Definitions for Discussion Spiritual Struggle : Any individual strain/strife including one's feeling of connection to the Divine, to religious foundations or to their lessons Religious Coping : One's endeavor ("positive" or "negative") to oversee stressors that in any capacity includes religious convictions, practices or assets

Slide 10

What is the predominance of otherworldly battle ? Since the idea remains differently and loosely characterized in the examination writing, appraisals of profound battle in the overall public are unclear. (Take note of: The exploration based human services writing takes after a to a great extent isolate stream of thought from that of the peaceful and philosophical writing.)

Slide 11

A Study of "Religious Conflict" in a General Population When a comfort test of 202 grown-ups in the southeastern US was gotten some information about encounters of religious clash that had happened "in a religious setting or with religious hints," 65% reacted with portrayals of contentions that were for the most part between individual in nature yet whose determination was intra - individual. — Nielsen, M. E., "An evaluation of religious clashes and their resolutions," Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 37, no. 1 (Mar 1998): 181-190.

Slide 12

A Study of "Religious Doubt" in a Denominational Population A national example of Presbyterians (1996-1997, barring ministers) was asked whether they had encountered questions about their confidence due to a) detestable on the planet, b) individual enduring, or c) feeling that life truly has no significance. The creators report: "just 35% of the members in this review showed they never experienced questions about their confidence." — See pp. 528-529 of Krause, N., et al., "Maturing, religious uncertainty, and mental prosperity," Gerontologist 39, no. 5 (October 1999): 525-533.

Slide 13

General Social Survey (GSS) for 1988-1991 An irregular example 1,481 grown-ups in the US was asked: How frequently have these issues brought on questions about your religious confidence: - - Percentages - - Never Sometimes Often Don't know  Evil in the world 49.8 36.2 10.7 2.1 Personal suffering 44.4 43.9 8.8 1.2 Feeling that life really 74.8 18.2 3.6 2.2 has no significance — Nat'l Opinion Research Ctr, U of Chicago

Slide 14

General Social Survey (GSS) for 1998 An arbitrary specimen 1,445 grown-ups in the US was asked: How regularly have these issues created questions about your religious confidence: - - Percentages - - Never Sometimes Often Don't know  Evil in the world 51.9 32.9 11.8 2.6 Personal suffering 51.4 36.5 8.7 2.6 — Nat'l Opinion Research Ctr, U of Chicago

Slide 15

More Results from the GSS for 1998 The 1998 example was additionally asked: Think about how you attempt to comprehend and manage real issues throughout your life. Whatever degree is each of the accompanying required in the way you adapt: - - Percentages - - Not Some-Quite An incredible Don't at all what a bit bargain know I ponder whether God has 85.3 9.3 1.7 1.2 1.0 relinquished me I feel that God is rebuffing 74.8 17.0 3.7 1.9 1.2 me for my transgressions or absence of most profound sense of being — Nat'l Opinion Research Ctr, U of Chicago

Slide 16

Methodological Issues Because of the nascency of Spirituality & Health as a field of research, fundamental methodological issues are very unsettled. For instance: What would we be able to quantify and in what ways? How might we discuss the subject and decipher how others discuss it? How might we investigate causal connections amongst otherworldly existence and wellbeing?

Slide 17

Problems in the investigation of profound battle • dialect of request (e.g., otherworldly versus religious or battle versus strife ) • social desire inclination in reactions • private and individual nature of the topic • quantitative measures still in an early period of general advancement • part of progress in profound battle • complex relationship to medical problems

Slide 18

Brief RCOPE 1) Looked for a more grounded association with God 2) Sought God's adoration and care. 3) Sought assistance from God in relinquishing my outrage. 4) Tried to put my arrangements vigorously together with God. 5) Tried to perceive how God may attempt to reinforce me in this circumstance. 6) Asked absolution of my transgressions. 7) Focused on religion to quit stressing over my issues. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8) Wondered whether God had deserted me. 9) Felt rebuffed by God for my absence of dedication. 10) Wondered what I accomplished for God to rebuff me. 11) Questioned God's affection for me. 12) Wondered whether my congregation had relinquished me. 13) Decided the fallen angel got this going. 14) Questioned the force of God.

Slide 19

Fitchett, G., et al., " Religious battle: pervasiveness, connects and psychological well-being dangers in diabetic, congestive heart disappointment, and oncology patients ," International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine 34, no. 2 (2004): 179-196. • Surveyed 71 diabetic outpatients, 70 congestive heart disappointment outpatients, and 97 oncology inpatients (independently) • Used the Brief RCOPE's Negative Religious Coping subscale to gauge negative religious adapting

Slide 20

Results from Fitchett… (2004) • 52% of the aggregate specimen showed no negative religious adapting on the seven-thing subscale of the Brief RCOPE • 15% of the aggregate example reacted "a lot" or "an extraordinary arrangement" to at least 2 of the negative religious adapting things — which the analysts attest constitutes critical battle that may put patients at hazard for poor mental or physical wellbeing results

Slide 21

Negative Religious Coping Responses (%) Not Some-Quite An incredible