Instructor Evaluations and Support for Effective Instruction

1503 days ago, 515 views
PowerPoint PPT Presentation
. The New Teacher Project (TNTP) schools areas and states satisfy the guarantee of government funded ensuring so as to train that all understudies

Presentation Transcript

Slide 1

Educator Evaluations and Support for Effective Instruction Florida Department of Education What's Working Series Tampa, Florida October 6, 2010

Slide 2

National philanthropic, established by instructors in 1997 Partners with school locale, state training organizations, and contract schools Targets intense educator quality difficulties Delivers a scope of altered administrations and arrangements on an expense for-administration premise Approx. 250 representatives, most implanted in school locale workplaces; larger part are previous instructors Past and exhibit customers include: Districts: Baltimore, Chicago, Denver, Memphis, New Orleans, New York, Oakland, Philadelphia, San Antonio, Washington, DC States: Alaska, Louisiana, Texas, Virginia The New Teacher Project (TNTP) schools regions and states satisfy the guarantee of government funded training by guaranteeing that all understudies—particularly those from high-require groups—get brilliant educators.

Slide 3

A huge accomplishment hole isolates white and minority understudies. By secondary school, minority understudies are four years behind white understudies. NAEP Grade 4 Reading NAEP Reading At age 17, African American and Latino understudies read at an indistinguishable levels from 13 year-old white understudies. Percent of Students Average Scale Score Notes: *Accommodations for understudies with incapacities and English dialect learners not allowed; Trends comparative for Math. Source : Original examination of the Education Trust in view of Long-Term Trends NAEP ; National Center for Education Statistics, NAEP Data Explorer, , NAEP 2004 Trends in Academic Progress

Slide 4

Research has demonstrated that viable instructors are the arrangement. Dallas understudies who begin 2 nd grade at about a similar level of math accomplishment… … complete 5 th grade math at significantly extraordinary levels relying upon the nature of their educators. After 3 EFFECTIVE Teachers 50 After 3 INEFFECTIVE Teachers Original investigation by the Education Trust. Source : Heather Jordan, Robert Mendro, and Dash Weerasinghe, The Effects of Teachers on Longitudinal Student Achievement , 1997.

Slide 5

Certification Has a One-Point Impact on Achievement Source: Gordon, Kane, Staiger, Identifying Effective Teachers Using Performance at work , The Hamilton Project, Brookings Institution, April 2006.

Slide 6

Two Years of Experience Has a Four-Point Impact

Slide 7

Impact of Effective Teachers is Ten Points

Slide 8

In many areas, human capital arrangements are inadequately adjusted.  A successful educator in each classroom  $  Policies and practices that prompt to incorrect assessments, making it hard to reward superior workers and comprehend the formative needs of low entertainers. Little meticulousness in residency choices. Not focused to high-require schools or subjects. Bureaucratic brokenness hinders candidates. Low-thoroughness interviews. Bygone opening strategies block production of viable groups. Dollars assembled at senior end of vocation, paying little heed to real instructor viability. Remuneration Recruitment Evaluation Hiring Screening Retention Development School Leadership Highest performing educators frequently leave the classroom the soonest. Instructors are expelled simply because of the most egregious activities. PD is not connected to individual assessments. It is driven by what suppliers offer, and its viability is infrequently evaluated. Least necessities; little thought for quality. Principals need expert, responsibility, apparatuses, motivations, and ability expected to deal with the execution of their instructors.

Slide 9

To acknowledge economical change, successful instructing must be the controlling worry behind all components of a locale's human capital framework. A viable educator in each classroom Working Conditions Recruitment School-Level Human Cap. Mgmnt. Choice Effectiveness Management Optimize viability of educator workforce. Center METRICS Talent Pipeline Create supply of compelling instructors to fill all opportunities. Center METRIC Number and rate of new instructors who exhibit viability over an objective limit Retention/Dismissal Training/Certification Compensation Hiring/Placement Evaluation/Prof. Dev. On-Boarding Measures of understudy learning

Slide 10

Dramatic changes in understudy accomplishment can't happen without a managed and vital concentrate on expanding instructor adequacy. 5 Boost adequacy of all instructors through viable assessment and focused on expert advancement. Objectives for Optimizing Teacher Effectiveness 2 Optimize new educator supply by procuring from readiness programs whose instructors reliably accomplish better understudy results. 1 Retain and use best educators. 3 Teacher Effectiveness in Improving Student Achievement 5 4 Improve or exit constantly less powerful instructors and supplant with more viable educators. Organize successful instructors for high-require understudies. Current educator execution Potential instructor execution

Slide 11

The Widget Effect "With regards to measuring instructional execution, current approaches and frameworks ignore huge contrasts between instructors . There is practically zero separation of amazing educating from great, great from reasonable, or reasonable from poor. This is the Widget Effect: an inclination to regard all educators as generally exchangeable, notwithstanding when their instructing is very factor. Thusly, educators are not created as experts with individual qualities and abilities, and poor execution is infrequently recognized or tended to ." The New Teacher Project, 2009

Slide 12

The Widget Effect in real life: When is instructor adequacy considered?

Slide 13

The Widget Effect in Teacher Evaluation: Summary of Findings

Slide 14

When numerous appraisals are accessible, instructors have a tendency to be alloted the most astounding evaluations and are once in a while appointed poor appraisals. Assessment Ratings for Tenured Teachers in Districts with Multiple-Rating Systems

Slide 15

In regions that utilization paired "Palatable/Unsatisfactory" rating frameworks, the "Inadmissible" rating is never utilized. Assessment Ratings for Tenured Teachers in Districts with Binary Rating Systems

Slide 16

Teachers report insufficient is being done to perceive and hold best entertainers as measured by their effect on understudy learning. 59% of instructors report their locale is not doing what's necessary to distinguish, perceive, adjust, advance and hold the best educators as measured by their effect on understudy learning. "All the great quality educators leave the region after only a couple of years. They require more motivating force to remain." "Some kind of acknowledgment or acclaim would be decent. Those making a decent or extraordinary showing with regards to are never told so." "On the off chance that you pay the sparkling stars the same as the good-for-nothings, you will diminish the sparkling stars and fortify the sloth of the good-for-nothings." "I, and others, buckle down on the grounds that we have a still, small voice, however I don't think [the district] considers us to be any not quite the same as the lower performing educators. Instructors who buckle down get next to no acclaim or notice." TNTP overview of 7,318 educators crosswise over four locales led May 2008 to April 2009

Slide 17

Weak assessment practices and frameworks imply that numerous instructors get minimal significant criticism. 39% of Denver instructors who had an advancement region recognized on their latest assessment "don't have the foggiest idea" which execution standard they neglected to meet. Source 1 : TNTP overview of 15,176 instructors crosswise over 12 locales led May 2008 to April 2009 Source 2 : TNTP study of 1,863 Denver Public School educators led November to December 2008

Slide 18

Teachers and principals concur that poor direction is unavoidable. "Are there tenured/non-trial educators in your school who convey poor direction?" (Percent reacting "Yes") Percent of All Ratings that Indicated "Unsuitable" Performance Source: TNTP study of 7,318 instructors crosswise over 4 locales led February to April 2009

Slide 19

Yet expulsion for poor instructional execution basically never happens. Recurrence of Teacher Dismissals for Performance (Non-Probationary Teachers) Note : During the day and age 2003-04 through 2007-08, Toledo Public Schools had five casual expulsions of tenured instructors (i.e., tenured educators who were prescribed for rejection however chose to leave or resign instead).  Data on casual expulsions were not accessible for all locale considered.

Slide 20

Our proposals are a suggestion to take action for school areas to move past treating educators like gadgets. Embrace an extensive execution assessment framework that reasonably, precisely and believably separates educators in view of their viability in advancing understudy accomplishment and gives focused on expert advancement to help them progress. Prepare executives and different evaluators in the educator execution assessment framework and consider them responsible for utilizing it adequately. Coordinate the execution assessment framework with basic human capital arrangements and capacities, for example, educator task, proficient advancement, remuneration, maintenance and rejection. ADDRESS reliably incapable educating through expulsion arrangements that give bring down stakes alternatives to inadequate educators to leave the region and an arrangement of due process that is reasonable yet productive. Proposals 1 2 "Instruction change will go no place until the states are compelled to patch up degenerate instructor assessment frameworks that rate a larger part of educators as "brilliant," even in schools where youngsters learn nothing." Editorial (6.10.09) 3 4

Slide 21

TNTP proposes another assessment structure intended to give valid information on instructor adequacy.  Set execution gauges in territories that are most firmly fixing to understudy learning .  Measure instructor adequacy and direction against execution norms.  Benchmark teache