Filter s Critique of Structural Functionalism

1721 days ago, 591 views
PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Drain's Scrutinize of Basic Functionalism. (proceeded). Inconsistencies in the Perfect Frameworks. 2. The Study of Social Change Kachin Slope region portrayed not by balance, but rather by a 'flimsy equilibirum' in persistent wavering:

Presentation Transcript

Slide 1

´╗┐Drain's Critique of Structural Functionalism (proceeded)

Slide 2

Contradictions in the Ideal Systems 2. The Critique of Social Change Kachin Hill range described not by balance, but rather by a 'shaky equilibirum' in persistent wavering: Between Gumsa and Gumlao, between social chains of importance and radical populism. I. Gumlao: all are of a similar status, no town or area boss, social and phonetic factionalism. II. Gumsa: perfect model is a medieval state, positioned chain of command in status and governmental issues. Dialects positioned in a status progressive system, with Jinghpaw being the dialect of the gentry. Both Gumlao and Gumsa people group are shaky, in light of the fact that they contain components in pressure with each other, I.e. inside inconsistencies

Slide 3

The Gumsa and Gumlao Models: GUMSA MODEL: Descent: Patrilineal genealogies and factions, ultimogeniture (most youthful child acquires), every ancestry headed by a senior. Allliance: Matrilateral cross-cousin marriage is the perfect. Factions are perfect exogamous, however quite often so at the level of the heredity. Prompts to the mayu-dama framework as far as understanding chain of importance: I. Mayu: heredities from which inner self's ancestry have taken ladies. II. Dama: ancestries in which ladies from personality's ancestry have as of late hitched. III. Lawu-lahta: perceived as drop relatives, however far off connections. Neither mayu nor dama. IV. Firmly related ancestries whom one can't wed into.

Slide 4

Contradictions of the Gumsa Model Mayu/dama relationship is various leveled. In the event that a child in-law can't give endowments as lady of the hour value, he should work for his dad in-law. Inclination is for the head of the town to attempt to act like a Shan sovereign (saohpa) and regard the dama connections as though they were medieval serfs. At one point the dama genealogies revolt, founding a gumlao "vote based system"

Slide 5

Contradictions in the Gumlao Model on a basic level, all heredities are equivalent and there ought to be no qualification between spouse providers and wife beneficiaries. Nonetheless, the wording and dialect of mayu and dama is held. More than a few eras, the mayu genealogies attempt to reassert their power by requiring high lady of the hour cost and the town starts to look like a gumsa dictatorship.

Slide 6

A Criticism of the Concept of "Tribe" as a Colonial Construct Tribe was recognized in functionalism by: I. Dialect: yet the Kachin Hills region does not fit this model. There are fifteen unmistakable dialects. Dialect and vernacular are identified with economic wellbeing. 2. Domain: Kachin and Shan are regularly combined up, liquid limits. Numerous cases of individual kachins who got to be Shan and the other way around 3. Political/Social Organization: Within the Kachin Hill Area, there are two particular "models" of society: Hence, none of the target meanings of tribe could be connected to the Kachin Hill territories.

Slide 7

Colonial ethnography Previous english works on the Kachin were composed by provincial adminstrators. They expected that tribe = single culture= given region = single dialect = "race." They clarified varieties in dialect and social qualities in the Kachin Hill territories as because of chronicled movements. Subsequently, Shan were Chinese who had moved to the Kachin swamps. Kachin dialects were Tibeto-Burmese, subsequently it was expected that the Kachin had moved from Tibet in before hundreds of years. Notwithstanding, these speculative histories did not fit the certainties of scattering of dialects and social qualities. For Leach, the major deciding distinction between the Kachin and Shan was biological: Shan were valley inhabitants, rehearsing wet-rice development and were Buddhist Kachin were slope occupants, subsistence agriculturalists and animists. Additionally look into demonstrated that many names of tribes that were thought to be settled were appllied by pilgrim overseers: E.g. Lao, Dene, and different words truly just signified 'our kin' in the particular dialect. Numerous more expamples of individuals intersection ethnic limits and of changing cynamics of ethnic gatherings were discovered: E.g. the Fur and Baggara in Sudan. E.g. The Nuer were truly "Dinka" previously.

Slide 8

Tribes as ethnic gatherings Individuals in the Kachin Hills utilized their ethnicity deliberately, in connection to outer political settings. Effective Kachin boss attempted to copy the Shan rulers. Some Kachin would relocate to the fields, learn Thai, get to be distinctly Buddhist and inside a couple of eras 'get to be Shan.' Similarly, individuals who lost their territory in the fields would move to the slopes and continuously get to be "Kachin." However, the stream of personell crosswise over ethnic limits did not eradicate the idea that there were contrasts between the slope occupants and the fields.

Slide 9

Ethnic gatherings and limits (Barth) Focus is on review ethnicity socially and as a procedure. Does not accept that common culture=shared language=shared territory= a solitary ethnic personality. Or maybe the issue turns into that of distinguishing the conditions under which ethnic limits are kept up and those under which they change. For ethnicities to exist, there needs to likewise be an idea of a limit amongst "us" and them. Coherence of an ethnic gathering presupposes the presence of a limit? How is this kept up? How does this change? Likewise, this approach gives essential accentuation to the way that ethnic character is a classification of attribution by the on-screen characters themselves.

Slide 10

Many Societies are Polyethnic Types of Ethnic Boundaries: at least two ethnic gatherings may involve unmistakable natural specialties and adventure distinctive assets, however might be connected through fuse in a polyethnic state or potentially through the market. Cooperation is probably going to be corresponding (Kachin/Shan). Showcase connection can leave wide regions of social assorted qualities untouched. They may corner isolate domains, yet exist together in the same environmental space, here regularly focused limits are delivered. They may offer integral merchandise and ventures for each other, in which case they might be correlative, additionally stratified. E.g. station or rank like frameworks. Development crosswise over ethnic limits will rely on specific monetary/ecologic/political conditions, e.g. Hide and Baggara.

Slide 11

To aggregate up: Focus now is on how social orders change. Additionally on the impact of outside variables, e.g. imperialism. Angles that had appeared to be "objective" and "settled" in time are currently observed to be developed and change through time, e.g. ethnic and "tribal" characters. The emphasis is on a social and processual way to deal with seeing how social gatherings and limits are CONSTRUCTED