Can Identifying the Causes of Poverty Give Insight into Eliminating Poverty

Presentation Transcript

Can Identifying the Causes of Poverty Give Insight into Eliminating Poverty? Thought's Conference "Advancement Experiences and Policy Options for a Changing World" Tsinghua University, Beijing 7 June 2007 Jan Kregel Senior Scholar, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College Distinguished Professor, Center for Full Employment and Price Stability, University of Missouri, Kansas City

How Does WB Measure Poverty? Making due on less that $1.00 every day Why $1.00? We don't have a logical measure of Poverty The mid-purpose of National Poverty Lines of 10 Developing Countries picked by the World Bank Expenditure in national money detailed in national family consumption reviews Converted to $US at PPP trade rates

Poverty Reduction as Development Strategy NGO's Target Poverty Pro-Poor arrangements World Bank Targets Poverty The MDGs Target Poverty The IMG Targets Poverty The fundamental apparatus of Policy is the Poverty Reduction Strategy

We need to know what it is before we know what causes it Like US Supreme Court on Pornography I know it when I see it The World Bank reveals to me what it is Governments Decide what it is NGO's choose what it is

Alternative Measures? Physical Caloric Intake Basic Needs Social - Demonstration Effect Political Universal Declaration of Human Rights Social Inclusion/Exclusion Economic Marginalization Participation in the Production Process Self-Subsistence Are Indigenous Peoples in Poverty?

How to Eliminate WB/MDGPoverty? GlobalWelfare Program – Moral Responsibility Official Development Assistance Income Transfers – to Increase Incomes External Provision of Social-Medical Services Creates: Aid Dependency Aid Fatigue Has not delivered comes about

But rather this does not disclose to us what Causes Poverty There are Poor People in Rich Countries There are Rich People in Poor Countries Is it a wage appropriation issue? Would redistribution make everybody poor? Individuals in Rich Countries would even now be wealthier than the People in Poor Countries Is it a Problem of the Level of Development?

Linking Poverty and Development "Neediness is neither an equivalent word for underdevelopment nor a reason for underdevelopment; it is just more symptomatic of a more broad issue. Neediness frames some portion of a culture. … Most much of the time the way of life of destitution creates when a stratified social and financial framework is separating or is being supplanted by another… Often it comes about because of Imperial victory in which the local social and monetary structure is crushed and the locals are kept up in a servile frontier status, in some cases for some eras. … The way of life of neediness is not indistinguishable in all settings … .it fluctuates from place to put and starting with one period then onto the next." Keith Griffin, Underdevelopment in Spanish America , Cambridge Massachusetts, MIT Press, 1969

Globalization and the Culture of Poverty Globalization Insertion in the International Trade and Financial System Washington Consensus Introduction of Monoeconomic Policy Structural Adjustment Policies Market Friendly Policies Shifting from Government Provision to Individual Responsibility &Market arrangement Profit Based Performance Criteria

Globalization, Development and Poverty Does destitution come about because of fast combination into the worldwide economy that disassembles the current social and monetary structure? Those without attractive aptitudes are underestimated and turned out to be socially prohibited? Joan Robinson – What if the General Equilibrium display creates a harmony wage that is beneath subsistence?

National Development Strategies Mandated in 2005 Global Summit Outcome To Include All Internationally Agreed Development Goals from the UN Conferences and Summits of the 1990s To Move Beyond MDGs To Move Beyond PRSPs To Provide Alternative Approaches for genuine national strategy space To consider Poverty to be a piece of the basic procedure of Economic and Social Development National Reponsibility for Poverty Reduction

Major Addition to Development Goals - Employment 2005 World Summit Paragraph on Employment High-level section of the 2006 substantive session of the Economic and Social Council Ministerial Declaration Make full and beneficial business and fair work for all, including for ladies and youngsters, a focal goal of applicable national and worldwide arrangements and national improvement systems and to be a piece of endeavors to accomplish the universally concurred advancement objectives, including the Millennium Development Goals.

Creating National Policy Space Fiscal Policy Space To bolster Social Safety Nets To bolster financial development To bolster business Monetary Policy Space Central Bank Policy underpins Fiscal Policy Domestically coordinated loan cost approach Exchange Rate Policy Contribution of Foreign Investment

National Policy Space requires Fiscal Sovereignty Is running an administration financial surplus sound asset mobilsation strategy? Government spending makes private area resources in the saving money framework Taxation makes private division obligations to the legislature that must be financed with those advantages If charges surpass government spending the private segment is in net shortfall, i.e. Indebted We no longer utilize account holders jail as discipline – just neediness If the private division holds resources for other comfort purposes budgetary security requires an administration shortfall after some time equivalent to the private part's interest for cash equalizations Government Deficit is Required for Growth

Domestic Policy Space requires Monetary Sovereignty Government shortage spending increments unborrowed bank saves Excess stores drive interbank offer rates to zero To keep financing costs positive the legislature must get As borrower of final resort it can simply settle the loan cost and the tenor at which it obtains Interest rates are hence not obliged by private area eagerness to purchase government obligation or the measure of the deficiency The administration does not need to acquire or issue obligation to shortage spend It takes after that the legislature can simply set the transient arrangement financing cost freely of the span of the deficiency Did expansive government obligation and government shortage cause financing costs to ascend in Japan in the course of the most recent 10 years?

What are the Limits to Sovereignty? Overhauling External Borrowing Creates Need for Negative Net Resource Flows Creates requirement for Emergency Liquidity Creates requirement for IMF program Imposes here and now Structural Adjustment and remotely decided changes in local financial and political structure Indonesia, Korea Argentina Leads to Increased Poverty National Monetary Sovereignty wipes out need to acquire remotely – preparation of residential assets

How to utilize strategy space to bolster activation of local work assets? In the event that private division advancement is deficient to give full business Government assumes liability to give work to every one of those ready and ready to work at or possibly underneath the predominant casual part wage

What does "work" mean? Diverse as per level of advancement Primary objectives: Maintain and enhance expertise level of the work constrain – fundamental instructive aptitudes Provide social security net – pay support Provide social incorporation for the unemployed/unemployable – social administrations Meet the necessities of female heads of families to consolidate work with family duties Improve the prosperity of society – valuable open works Eliminating the Culture of Poverty

Can it be finished? Argentina encounter – Jefes program Education at all levels an essential piece of the program – essential to word related Interministerial collaboration – Labor, Eduction and Social Development services participate in giving instructive program Promotes work practice and experience Provides professional abilities Integrates peripheral groups Supports Gender Equality Creates entrepreneurial Skills Counters Culture of Poverty

Is Jefes an important case? Confirmed cases of achievement Verified cases of extortion and defilement Depends intensely on nearby government for usage Depends vigorously on people Depends on Federal government for financing Constrained by government spending plan goals– however require not be given money related and monetary power that Argentina at present has

Jefes is not ELR The Jefes program was near the ELR proposition yet was a crisis reaction to the emergency A reasonably composed ELR can expand on the accomplishment of Jefes It can be intended to coordinate the MDGs and additionally the other Internationally Agreed Development Goals to be incorporated into the National Development Strategies commanded at the 2005 Global Summit It Can Contribute to the Elimination of the Culture of Poverty

ELR as a MDG/Poverty Reduction program An appropriately outlined ELR program to give work can likewise be intended to fulfill: MDG Goal 1: Eradicate Extreme Hunger and Poverty MDG Goal2: Universal Primary Education MDG Goal 3: Promote Gender Equality and Empower Women MDG 4 and 5 Reduce Child Mortality and Improve Maternal Health